Founding Partner
In 2023, patent news became more crucial than ever. As technology and innovation accelerate, understanding the latest patent developments is key for businesses and inventors alike. From groundbreaking AI advancements to significant legal reforms, this past year saw many significant developments in patent law.
The Evolution of AI and Patent Law
The evolution of AI in 2023 significantly reshaped the landscape of patent law. As AI systems became more sophisticated, capable of creating inventions independently, the legal community faced a pivotal question: can AI be recognized as an inventor? This year, the most notable case regarding AI and patent law, Thaler v. Vidal, involved an AI system named “DABUS.” The legal debates surrounding DABUS focused on whether an AI system could be legally recognized as an inventor. This issue was brought to various patent offices and courts around the world, including in the United States, the United Kingdom, and the European Union.
In the U.S., the United States Patents and Trademarks Office (USPTO) rejected patent applications for the inventions created by DABUS because the inventor was not a person. The appeals court upheld this decision, and in 2023, the Supreme Court refused to review the case, leaving in place the USPTO’s decision requiring inventors to be natural persons. This case has sparked a global conversation on the role of AI in the future of innovation and intellectual property rights.
Big Pharma and Patent Clashes
In 2023, the Biden administration made a back-door attempt to address high prescription drug prices, focusing on drugs developed from taxpayer-funded research. Because government funds contribute to biomedical research leading to new medications, the government proposed a framework to exercise “march-in rights,” under the Baye Doyle Act, which for years had been understood to apply in social emergencies to ensure drugs could be manufactured and distributed to the population at large, and was not intended by Congress when drafted to serve as a means to reduce drug prices.
This action followed years of declined requests to use march-in rights for overpriced drugs, including the recent case with the prostate cancer drug Xtandi. This initiative, which in the short term could result in reduced drug prices, but in the long term reduce the creation of new medicines, was led by the Department of Health and Human Services and the Department of Commerce.
Patent Application Developments
In May 2023, the Supreme Court unanimously ruled in the pivotal patent law case Amgen, Inc. v. Sanofi which involved Amgen’s cholesterol-lowering drug patents. The Court found that Amgen’s patents did not meet the Patent Act’s enablement requirement. Amgen’s patents, which aimed to cover all antibodies that bind and block a receptor involved in LDL cholesterol metabolism, were deemed too broad as they failed to describe the invention with sufficient particularity for a “skilled artisan” to make and use the claimed invention.
This ruling sets a significant precedent in patent law, emphasizing the importance of detailed specifications in patent applications, especially for claims covering broad classes of inventions. It underscores the balance between encouraging innovation and avoiding overbroad claims that can stifle further research and development.
Sustainability and Green Patents
In 2023, sustainability and green technology patents took center stage, reflecting a growing commitment to environmental innovation. As the world grappled with climate change, patents in renewable energy, waste reduction, and eco-friendly materials surged. These green patents are pivotal in driving sustainable practices across industries, offering exclusive rights to novel solutions that address environmental challenges. They not only incentivize companies to invest in green technology but also play a crucial role in shaping a more sustainable future. The surge in green patents underscores the synergy between environmental responsibility and economic progress, fostering a new era of eco-conscious technological advancement.
Contact an Experienced Patent Attorney
Staying abreast of patent news can not only inform strategic decisions but also help you navigate the realm of intellectual property rights in an increasingly digital world. If you’re looking to protect your innovative ideas, don’t hesitate to reach out to Gearhart Law. Our experienced team is dedicated to providing you with tailored guidance and robust legal support to ensure your inventions are securely patented and your rights are fully protected. Contact us today to learn how we can help you succeed in this ever-evolving legal landscape.