Founding Partner
Last Updated: May 6, 2025
In the world of business agreements, one question often comes up: Can a written contract be legally binding if only one party has signed it? While a signature is often considered a critical element in solidifying a contract, the reality is more complex. Here, we explore the legal implications of unsigned or partially signed agreements under New Jersey contract law.
What Makes a Contract Legally Binding?
At its core, a contract requires the following elements:
- An offer by one party,
- Acceptance of that offer by the other,
- Consideration, or something of value exchanged, and
- Mutual intent to create legal obligations.
While many envision contracts as formal documents signed by both parties, New Jersey law does not always require a signature to make a contract enforceable. Oral contracts, electronic agreements, and other forms of mutual assent may also carry legal weight.
Do You Need Both Signatures for a Contract to Be Enforceable?
In many cases, both parties signing a contract is ideal—but not strictly required. A contract signed by only one party can still be valid if the other party demonstrates acceptance through words, actions, or conduct. For example, if one party begins performing duties under the agreement or accepts benefits from it, a court may view the contract as binding.
The Role and Significance of Signatures
A signature traditionally symbolizes consent to the terms of a contract. It confirms that a party has read, understood, and agreed to the agreement. But under modern contract law, especially in New Jersey, courts often focus on the intent to be bound—rather than the mere presence of signatures. This emphasizes the principle that the essence of a contract lies not just in formalities but in the clear intention to enter into a binding agreement.
Electronic signatures, email confirmations, and even text messages may serve as valid evidence of agreement. This is especially true in commercial settings where speed and efficiency often replace formalities.
Can You Enforce a Contract If the Other Party Didn’t Sign It?
Yes, a contract can sometimes be enforced even if the other party did not sign it. Courts will look at whether the unsigned party behaved as though they accepted the agreement. This could include:
- Starting performance under the agreement,
- Accepting goods, services, or payments,
- Sending emails or messages confirming agreement,
- Failing to object to the terms after receiving the contract.
In such cases, the unsigned party’s actions may substitute for a signature. However, the burden is on the enforcing party to prove that both sides intended to be bound. This is why clear documentation and legal counsel are essential.
Exceptions and Considerations
There are situations where signatures are required by law, such as:
- Real estate transactions,
- Certain employment agreements,
- Contracts governed by the Statute of Frauds.
In these cases, a missing signature may render the contract unenforceable. Always check the applicable legal requirements for your specific agreement.
How to Protect Yourself in Contractual Agreements
To reduce the risk of disputes and protect your legal rights:
- Always use written contracts with clearly defined terms,
- Ensure all parties sign the agreement whenever possible,
- Keep copies of all communications, including emails and text confirmations,
- Consult a commercial law attorney before entering into high-value or complex agreements.
Signatures are important, but they are just one part of a larger legal picture. In business law, clarity, conduct, and documentation often matter just as much.
Contact an Experienced New Jersey Contract Law Attorney
At Gearhart Law, we help businesses protect their interests through strong, enforceable contracts. Whether you’re drafting a new agreement or dealing with an unsigned one, our team provides personalized guidance rooted in New Jersey contract law. Contact us today for a consultation and take the next step toward legal peace of mind.